Android

My Google Pixel 8 Experience And Allergic Reaction to Fingerprinting, The Digital Kind At Least

by

This blog has been around for 22 years, so there are definitely themes I circle back to. One of them is my strange, recurring relationship with Android phones. Even though I’m primarily an Apple user, I’ve probably owned more Android devices than most self-identified Android fans. The pattern is always the same: I buy one as a secondary device, I use it for a while, then it sits unused, and eventually I sell it. Time passes, I forget why I swore them off, and I start the cycle again. I even wrote a note to Future Scott to warn me away from doing it again.

In principle, I avoid Google services wherever I can. I don’t use Chrome, I don’t use Gmail, and I shut down Google accounts once I’m done with them. And yet, every so often, I’ll find myself picking up a Pixel or some other Android device, which of course requires opening yet another Google account. I tell myself it’s just a dabble, nothing serious.

Late last year I bought a Pixel 8. At first, I was happy enough with it. It was a solid device, smooth to use, and it scratched that itch of trying something different. But right after I bought it, Google announced they were changing how tracking would work on their phones and browsers. Instead of traditional identifiers you could reset or mask, they were moving to device fingerprinting. In plain terms, that means every Google phone and browser gets a permanent, unique tag. You can’t get rid of it, you can’t change it, and you certainly can’t hide from it.

For someone like me, who’s allergic to oversharing by default, the idea of being permanently tagged at the device level was a dealbreaker. It didn’t matter how polished the hardware was; I couldn’t stomach it. I did a bit of threat modeling on my own use case, read up on the details, and then stopped using the Pixel. A few months later I sold it. I should have sold it sooner, but it was only a secondary device and I didn’t feel much urgency. I defaulted back to an older iPhone I had lying around.

Not long after I sold the Pixel, Google partially backtracked on their fingerprinting plans. Sort of. The walk-back wasn’t enough to matter to me. By then I had already closed out my latest Google account, and I’m hoping that’s the end of the cycle. No more Groundhog Day moments of buying another Pixel, dabbling for a bit, and regretting it all over again.

For me, the line was crossed when the tag became something I couldn’t remove. Control matters. Once that was gone, so was my willingness to keep using the phone.

A Note To My Future Self On Why I Do Not Use Android Phones

by

In July before my trip to Bangkok i picked up a mid range Android Phone. I opted for the Motorola G7 since it offered dual SIM cards. I got the phone for less than 200 pounds. An iPhone that would do that was several times more than that. My need was for a dual SIM phone so i could keep my UK SIM and have a Bangok one. Then when I went to NY for most of August I would also have a US SIM and my UK SIM card.

My intentions mostly worked out the way i wanted it. As much as I prefer iOS for many reasons the new Android was ok. I liked the big screen for a cheap price. I wasn’t happy about some of the security trade off’s however i was letting that go and being in deial about it.

I then put in a Pi-hole as my DNS at home. Looking at the metrics from that made it impossible to be in denial as to how bad my Android phone probibly was to violating my privacy after i clicked on agreeing to whatever terms and conditions. The cover photo is a graph of my entire DNS queries in my house for a 24 hour period. The part on the right where there is a huge spike is purely my Motorola G7 making calls out to the internet. Doing what i am not 100% clear since i wasn’t using the phone. It just got on wifi and started phoning home alot.

The photo below shows that the same Android phone is one the chattiest device on my network at home and also gets its requests blocked more than any other device. For a phone that i dont use alot and wasn’t in my house for most of the 24 hour period measured that is pretty creepy. To put it in context M and i have iPhones and iPads and none of them get blocked or “talk” on the internet that much if we are not using them.

The Motorola G7 in question is being reset to factory defaults and wiped as I write this article. It will get sold on ebay shortly. This entire episode highlights why I had reservations about Android as a technology in the first place. It is slick however the trade off on my privacy is not worth it. i would rather save longer and keep using iOS.

The Story of Yet Another Android Phone I Wont Have For Long

by

In late July I went to the car phone warehouse in the mall at Canary wharf and bought a new Nokia 6.1 android phone. I have been on and off again if I wanted to purchase another android phone. A month or so ago I was in the same store and opted not to buy something. At the time I was convinced history would repeat itself and I would buy a phone simply to return it or sell it in a few months. That is what i have tended to do with Android phones. That may still be the case with this phone. My motivation this time around was I wanted a pretty big screen compared to the iPhone SE that I got from work.

The intention is to use this phone for work and have it be the only device i have the work management apps on. I am trying to keep the annoying work management applications off my personal iPhone X. The challenges the iPhone that I get from work has a tiny screen then I can’t really see any more. Instead of spending huge amounts of money out of my own pocket on work phone I figured I would splurge on an entry level android phone with the big screen to use for work applications.

I won’t use android for personal use due to my security concerns that I’ve outlined previously. I’m a little concerned about using it at all however for work applications I am less worried. Yes for those die hard people reading this i know that my location will be leaked to google and a whole bunch of other things issues with data collection they may have on me. For now I am not ok with it but willing to try the phone anyway. It’s like i know that cup cake is bad for me or that Amazon Echo in my office is bad for me. I eat it and have it but know i will likely have to deal with it somehow later.

My goal is to uninstall the work management application on my personal number. I have been lazy so having it on my personal phone has been nice. The final straw for me was my company switched management applications a few months ago. The new one requires you to change your PIN code frequently. It’s annoying and unnecessary and certificates and email application.

I started debating about purchasing an android phone a few months ago. At the time I opted to avoid android and see if I can make it work with the smaller screen iPhone for work. Recently I’ve been reconsidering my decision so I started researching options. I narrowed my options down to the Moto G6 plus for the new Nokia 6.1. Both phones reviewed very well. The Moto G6 plus seemed to come out on top in every review I read.. In any event it was close. I opted for the Nokia because it offers android one and a pretty plain-vanilla OS experience. That means in theory quicker upgrades to the operating system. For me that was a bigger selling point than all the other minor advantages the Moto G6 plus had. All reviews complained about the Moto reputation for slow operating system upgrades. That is a no no for me.

My first impressions of the phone are generally positive, for an android phone. The build quality seems pretty good. It’s a metal and glass phone. Some reviews questioned the screen quality. I don’t need super high density screens because I have enough trouble seeing things. This room is big bright and clear for me. For what I’m going to use it for it’s been perfectly fine so far. As expected my biggest issues with the phone are really with the android operating system and nothing with the hardware.

The android OS as always has been experience for me feels more customizable however clunkier to use than iOS. Using android phone means the trade-off that I cannot get texts from my personal number on this phone since I cannot use Apple messages.

Other annoyances with the operating system android ecosystem more specific is that my play store account can only be one region time. I can only change the region or country once every year. I thought Apple handled multicountry options poorly. At least Apple lets me switch between two accounts. Not sure if I can do the same with my play account. I have to try the same with the google play store.

I do like how the management app segregates the work apps from the personal ones. Is that and the bigger screen worth the security trade offs i know i am making by just carrying the phone? I am not sure. I like it however part of me already regrets having it. I am going to give myself a month at minimum to see if i use it and like it before deciding if it goes onto eBay.

Apples Perception Problem

by

Apple has a perception problem if when I am out to dinner our waiter is arguing with me that he bought an Android Wear watch because Android is more “open” than Apple.  I am cool if you want to live Android over iOS however liking Android because it is more open means that Google is successful at spinning how their OS is perceived and Apple hasn’t been.

I smartly dropped the topic and two other friends of mine agreed it was not worth the conversation.  MC and my friends wife just rolled their eyes at us (literally or figuratively).  It did all start because MC asked him if he was wearing an Apple Watch this whole thing would never have started.  I thought the whole conversation was pretty funny.

I Finally Killed Off Google Doc’s

by

I have finally succeeded in killing off any remaining documents i had hosted in my personal google account.  This action was a bit harder than i expected it would be.  I won’t go into further details on a public post due to security concerns however i am glad that I was able to go through and move everything i still needed and delete everything I didn’t need.  Exporting data was easy to an offline file but moving things that others still needed to collaborate on was a challenge and requires giving out new URL’s unless i was moving the document to someone else in the same google work domain.  I wasn’t doing that so it was challanging.

This milestone was one of the last I need before I can delete my remaining google app’s id that i used to use as my main account.  The last milestone may be the most difficult but that will be the topic of another post, Android Apps.

 

Android vs iOS

by

I am not a professional reviewer. I want to get that out there first thing. I have wrote about my opinions and comparisons of technology products in the past I am well aware that any number of people have written about this subject. I am writing about it because I continually try to be open minded and it has been very difficult to do so when comparing IOS to Android.

I can safely say that I’ve used regularly all of the major mobile operating systems in the past 10 years. I have owned many generation Treo’s with the Palm OS. I can’t even count the number of blackberries I’ve had. I have used three or four Symbian devices and loved my Nokia E60 for the 6 or 8 months I had it before I got my iPhone 3G.  I have tried numerous Android devices, and even had a few windows mobile phones.  I mention all that because I am not someone who just gets Apple stuff by default.  I look like that but that is a credit to Apple for making great devices and software.  I actually have only been buying Android devices because I didn’t want to be so reliant on Apple. My observations started between Android & iOS only because I wanted to see what was out there.

As a technology person on paper iOS has problems and Android looks promising.  What I mean by that is if I read anywhere else that an operating system and an ecosystem was so restrictive as Apple’s was I probably wouldn’t try it.  When you dig a little deeper that restrictiveness some of my Android friends like to complain about actually makes some sense.  it provides for a more stable phone.  It really does.  I have seen it between my iPhone and several Android devices.  I do not want to go back to the days were I reboot my phone every few hours like i did with my Treo 600.  Lack of true multi-tasking on iOS is another item that when it was announced iOS would be that restrictive i was turned off by it.  Now Apple has come up with interesting ways to let you think you have multitasking but still limiting it and thus reducing power usage.  Restrictive yes, but in the end it probably helps the overall experience.

On the other hand that restrictiveness has a drawback.  On my Galaxy Nexus I love the Locale app that changes settings based on my location and time of day.  My ringer goes off at night except for some work numbers.  My Google Voice # would change to point to my desk phone when I was at work and Skype when I was at home.  Come on that is cool.  Using that same example though, one of the best plugin’s for that app has a big note saying it is buggy and the developer does not suggest using it.  Really? If it crashes the phone then block it.  Apple would.  I know its heavy handed but the idea here is to be transparent as possible but have the customers interests at heart.

There are plenty more examples.  The last big one i would highlight is the fact that iOS is again restrictive on how the UI of apps look.  Sounds bad on paper, its apple being restrictive again.  Only problem is have you looked at Android apps?  How about comparing them to iOS apps.  Not just any iOS apps.  Compare something to the same app on iOS.  Apples restrictiveness gives the customer a consistent user experience.  Androids openness give you an inconsistent experience.  As a user i have been frustrated by this.  Heck I still don’t know what some of the dam icons mean on my Nexus 7.  Apple uses icons also but they just come across as more intuitive.  Getting back to that app comparison.  I have used many apps on both platforms.  When I bought my first Android phone that is what i did.  I went through making sure i could get the same experience on Android I had with iOS.  For the most part i found the same apps for Android that i had on iOS or ones that did the same thing.  Problem was they weren’t comparable.  Sometimes in features, but mostly in general look and feel and polish.  Some have improved over time but Apple still has better looking apps.  Foursquare, Facebook, Lastpass, Yelp, to name a few of the ones that I have had issues with.  The last aspect of user experience I would question is Exchange mail support.  Its built in to both platforms now but have you used the email app on Android.  Not the Gmail app because that is actually a great app.  I do give them credit for that.  I am talking about the regular email app.  Or the calendar app.  Using them on Android for my exchange mail was horrible.  It is just plain ugly and clunky to use.  iOS mail app may have its problems but it is intuitive and nice to look at.  Even the 3rd party apps such as Touchdown were horrible looking and I stopped using them after their trial ended.  That exchange limitation alone is a show stopper for me.

The theme I have seen with Android is that the apps work but they leave me wanting to go back to my iPhone or iPad.  Thats the problem.  I have gotten these devices wanting to be swept away and to sell my iOS stuff on eBay, but every time I get one I end up back with Apple.  Android keeps getting better but its been 4 years and they still aren’t that close in my opinion.

By now its clear I am in the Apple camp, but I really don’t want to be.  Given the opportunity I would switch.  The 5 or more Android phones I have had since using iPhones are an indication I do want to try.  Of course in the end I have a new iPhone 5 and an iPad Mini on order.  With those purchases Apple has locked me in for another year or two.  I will see how the landscape looks then, and maybe my own personal opinion may change.

 

Jaybird Bluetooth Headphones

by

For at least 2 years or more I have owned a pair of Jaybird Sportsband 2 headphones.  When I first bought them I thought they were very cool but never really started wearing them as a replacement to wired headphones.  I had a few issues with skipping or other sound issues with the headphones and my iPhone 4.  I also had some freak issue were the iPhone crashed and needed to be restored from a backup.  It happened when I was using my Jaybird

It wasn’t until I wanted to control volume and skip, play & pause on my Android phone did I look to the Jaybird headphones again.  I don’t have a wired headphone that will do that with the Android phone so after I moved to Woodside and now spend much more time on the train I started trying them with my Android phone.  The setup worked really well.  I am not sure when it happened but instead of using them with my Android phone I started using them with my iPhone 4S.

Now after wearing them for a year I am finding wearing wireless headphones especially on the way to and from work and doing laundry to be great.  I don’t know why I didn’t really get into them for almost a year of owning them.

The headphones feel a bit uncomfortable after a long period of time so i may shop around for more comfortable ones.

First Day in London

by

I spent the morning getting from the airport to the hotel. And I unwound a little. I walked over to Canary wharf mall near where the office is. I need to get a SIM card for my Galaxy Nexus phone and iPad. I was impressed at how easy it was to get, and the price was not that bad either.  I wasn’t happy I couldn’t use my AT&T iPhone 4S because it was locked to AT&T, but I was glad I had an unlocked Galaxy Nexus that i could use.

I tried to have some breakfast at Starbucks but ended up just having a Danish because he did not have the sandwich I wanted.  After that i headed out to meet Colin by the London bridge station.  Well first it was at another station and i didn’t see my text until i was already at the location i was originally going to.  I then turned around and headed to the London bridge station.  It was only a 15 minute detour.  Once there Colin was running late.  I walked around a bit, then just goofed off on the internet and read a bit in the sun until he arrived.

We checked out an open air market.  had some food.  I got some fudge.  We then walked and had a drink at a pub.  After that we walked all the way down towards were we were going to eat dinner.  it was right near the London Eye.  We walked along the river.  it was fun.  We were early meeting his wife so we had a drink outside by the river.  i tried Pims for the first time.  Colin insisted.  it was good.  We then meet his wife and had dinner, and then they had to rush off to get a delivery.  We parted ways at the tube station.  I made my way back to the hotel.

It was a good finally meeting Colin.  I considered him a friend for a quite some time since I start working at Reuters, however other than Skype video chat’s we have never met in person.

My Barely A Week With The Nexus One

by

Back in December I tried T-Mobile and the G1 out as a possible alternative for my iPhone.  The idea was that T-Mobile’s no contract plans might work out for me and if I liked the Android OS enough I would get a newer Android phone to replace my iPhone 3GS.  That experiment ended badly due to the G1 being no where near the iPhone and T-Mobile service sucking as bad or worse than AT&T did where I use it.

I have been eying the Nexus One for a little while since they offer an AT&T version of it.  It is the latest in Android phones and it has some advantages over the iPhone in hardware.  That and it used the same network my iPhone did I was curious to see if I could make the switch to the Nexus One and Android.  I keep saying the iPhone is the best phone I ever had but I would love to get rid of it so I figured I would give it a try.

I bought the Nexus One off of Google’s site.  It arrived the next day.  I give them props for that.  Unlike the G1, the Nexus One hardware was very nice.  Call quality was great, the screen was amazing and sharp.

I will cover in another post my switch from Zimbra (hosted at 01.com) to Google Apps.  I had to make this switch for this test to really work well, but I had been pondering this switch independently of the phone test for a while also.  The point is with a Gmail/Google Apps account setup the process of setting up my contacts, mail, and calendar on the new phone was totally painless.  The fact that Google Voice only works with an associated Gmail account and not Google Apps is a down side, but I survived.

I was all set to jump into the Android OS.  My original plan was to force myself to switch and use the Nexus One for a month.  By that point I will have either wanted to stick with it, or the new rumored iPhone would be out and or announced.  In reality I got only a few days (and not even using the phone for full days) before I threw in the towel.

On the plus side most of the apps I used on my iPhone had equivalent apps on Android.  I would say the vast majority of the apps I used had some sort of replacement on the Android.  The caveat to that is most of them were the Android versions were no where near as good as the iPhone versions.  They either were functionally inferior or just visually looked bad.  The option of more types of apps still had me interested.  Like the ability to have a caller ID app run all the time, or a location based profile app run all the time both were great ideas and reasons why I wanted an Android for multi tasking.  But those advantages were short lived when most of the apps I was used to using weren’t as good.  I have read others talk about this on Android and I can’t understand how reviewers can say Android will beat iPhone until this is fixed.

One major downside that may have pushed me over the edge in not wanting to use this phone was its music player.  I bought a cheap app to sync my itunes playlists to the phone so i was happy about that, but there was no easy way to use the music player when the phone was locked.  With the iPhone when the phone is locked you only have to double tap the round button and you get music controls.  That is huge! If i wanted to get to the same controls on the Android phone when it was locked I had to hit the power button, swipe my finger to unlock and then either have a music widget on my home screen or swipe over to another home screen with the music widget on it.  That just bothered me to no end.  Then I realized the Android OS doesn’t come with a video player.  Really?  And this is supposed to be a nice easily replacement for every day consumers?

The final straw for me was when I was editing an email and I couldn’t use my finder to highlight or move the cursor.  I can with the iPhone (well you have to with the iphone since that is the only input), but with the Nexus One you need to use the trackball.  Why?  I don’t want to use a trackball.  I don’t for anything else, but you kinda have to with this function.  Little things like that bothered me with this phone.  I have read that people say Android is not as “polished” as the iPhone.  They are right.  It isn’t.  I am a savy technical person (or I like to think so) and this stuff bothered me, so not sure what the average consumer would think.  I know several friends who are average consumers who love their Android phones.  My friend Dave just got a new Incredible.  I just don’t get how they are happy, but then again they haven’t used an iPhone.  I chalk it up to each person has their own tastes.

On the flip side Google Voice was fantastic on the Nexus One.  If anything that was one of the main reasons why I tried this experiment.  This plus couldn’t make up for all the short comings.

Lastly the fact that shopping for apps is only possible on the phone was a problem for me.  It worked out ok, but I like to browse on the computer and then send stuff to my iPhone.  Minor issue but still why can’t there be some sort of over the air sync?

In the end I got a few days out of the phone.  I am not worried.  It is in mind condition and will go up onto ebay in a few days.  Android may be popular and someone will be very happy with this phone, but I am happy drinking the cool aid and I am sticking with my iPhone 3GS.  Well until Apple announces something new this month!

eBay Items

by

I go through phases where I sell a bunch of stuff on eBay. I always say eBay is my enabler to buy more gadgets. It is kinda true. I sold 3 things this week and I boxed them up and they will ship out tomorrow.

I am parting with my G1 that I bought second hand in December. I was hoping to like Android and that T-Mobile would have worked by my apartment and at work. T-Mobile didn’t work well in either locations and I wasn’t such a fan of Android so far, so I am sticking with my iPhone and AT&T even if I have signal issues at work. Honestly I had this G1 sit around for a while since I only used it for about a week in December but was lazy to sell.

I am also selling my Archos 5 Internet Tablet. This was another Android experiment. I was hoping for something with a bigger screen than the iPhone to use as a tablet. Well I wasn’t a huge fan. It was a great device but, just not for me. I am going to wait for the much larger iPad instead.

I am also finally selling an extra magic mouse that I got by accident.

Next up on the to sell list is some larger stuff.